In this blog post, we’ll be
discussing about 2 research papers that dealt with participatory design for
elderly and children group. For each paper, we’ll be discussing how these 2
papers are interesting and the lesson learnt from it.
Paper 1:
Intelligent
Mobility Aid for Older People
Paper Title: Applying user centred and participatory design approaches to commercial product development.
Seniors, like any other demographic group, are not monolithic, and
there are important distinctions in their tech adoption patterns, beginning
with age itself. The literature talks about UCDs (User Centric designs). We are
focusing on elderly people as users to new technology. One of the most
important factor in quality of life for older adults is their ability to move
about independently. This lack of involvement in the design and evaluation
stages of product development may be responsible for causing some of the
generational and age-related issues that preclude a large proportion of the
populace interacting with products and may explain older peoples’ reluctance to
engage with new technology. The intention is that UCDs approach will provide
salient solutions that work as effectively for less able users as they do for
more able users. Similarly, participatory design aims to develop technologies
with the close involvement of stakeholders and end-users through cycles of
requirements gathering, prototype development, implementation, and evaluation (Wilkinson and De Angeli 2014). The concern expressed was that designers may assume that all
users possess the same cognitive and physical abilities as themselves, and a
failure to connect with all potential user groups may risk alienating or
excluding significant proportions of the population.
The fact that design practice is resource constrained, often in
terms of time, financial investment, and professional expertise, causes user
involvement to be seen as an expensive luxury that is not always necessary.
However, from a commercial management perspective, involving users within the
process can immediately improve the applicability, acceptance, and adoption of
the end design, and consequently has the potential to reduce development risk.
Which can be related to Investigating context of use and prior experience of
user. To implement such design we need to apply user centered design in an
experimental setting. One approach to achieve product differentiation is to
examine how humans learn and interact with interfaces and designs, and by
understanding more about how learning occurs, use this knowledge to influence
future design in terms of ease of learning, use, and access to all(Wilkinson and De Angeli 2014). Assistive technology for older adults has the immediate purpose
of increasing independence and allowing mastery of everyday activities, with
more distal benefits for well-being. However, despite great advances in the
sophistication of assistive technologies, they have yet to fulfil their promise
of promoting a better quality of life in older adults(Bright and Coventry 2013).
Ageing is associated with a decrease in mobility and social
interaction, and this can have detrimental effects upon access to good nutrition,
leisure, and other activities. Increasing the mobility of older adults
increases opportunities for social interaction and has positive effects upon
individual health and well-being. However, older adults may be less confident
in their ability to go out independently in unfamiliar and crowded spaces. The
Devices for Assisted Living (DALi) project pursued autonomous mobility through
the development of a mobility aid that supports navigation in crowded and
unstructured spaces by acquiring sensory information, anticipating the intent
of the individual or user, and determining a path that poses minimal risk of
collision. There are many other technologies that are dealing with same issue
such as the control system for a personal aid for mobility and health monitoring
(PAMM) for the elderly is presented. PAMM is intended to assist the elderly
living independently or in senior assisted living facilities. It provides
physical support and guidance, as well as monitoring basic vital signs for
users that may have both limited physical and cognitive capabilities. This
paper presents the design of a bi-level control system for PAMM. The first
level is an admittance-based mobility controller that provides a natural and
intuitive human machine interface. The second level is an adaptive shared
controller that allocates control between the user and the computer based on
metrics of the user's performance. Field trials at an eldercare facility show
the effectiveness of the design.
One initial task for the team developing the intelligent mobility
device was to examine how older users currently used walking-aids to assist in
daily tasks such as shopping, and how people in such shared environments
reacted to them. Initial laboratory studies investigated how a group of 25
students interacted within the same shared space e in this instance, a
simulated shopping environment. How these activities were planned and executed,
and how subsequent interaction was influenced was revealed by video-recording
participants’ physical behavior, and with the use of talk-aloud protocols
capturing both the thought and decision making processes that occurred. Further
studies were envisaged to observe older users engaged in the task of shopping
to investigate and discuss exactly what the task of shopping means to older
people, how they currently approach the task, and how technology could be
developed to assist them effectively. It can only be achieved by understanding
in greater detail the complexities and holistic experience of potential users
through direct user involvement throughout the design process.
Methodology: Mobility Aid Study
Critical instances within the verbal protocols were pre-defined as
any reference to physical, visual or auditory agent-to-agent awareness or
interaction, and these were then mapped to the video-footage to explore the
physical interactions described. Analysis of these critical instances allowed
them to be categorized by a single observer into two groups, namely: Active
Behaviors and Reactive Behaviors. Active behaviors were considered to be
behaviors employed to understand the environment and determine goal strategies
toward stack completion, environmental awareness and negotiation, mainly
focusing around the visual modality:
1. Eye-to-eye negotiation of immediate shared space interaction
2. Use of peripheral vision in assessment
3. Visual scanning of environment
4. Verbal interaction
Alternatively, Reactive behaviors were considered as the reactions
of agents in the environment to other agents; the physical reactive movements
made to accommodate other agents and successful interaction:
5. Waiting for free space or desired location to become clear
6. Stepping backwards to allow others more room/free space
7. Moving forwards to allow others more room/free space
8. Stationary agent yielding to moving agent
9. Move left
10. Move right
One another case study deals with wheelchair product design. With
the aim to develop a wheelchair product for athletic users, four active
wheelchair users were approached to contribute towards the initial requirements
analysis and specification stages. Being professional, international
paralympians, these four individuals were considered lead users as their use
and demands from a product are seen to be ahead of the market. The intention is
that this inclusive, participatory, approach can be seen to be of value in
obtaining a more accurate picture of user requirements and reactions to
prototypical design solutions and, in a wider context, will contribute towards
the explorative development of assistive technology that is more usable,
understandable, and intuitive, to a larger market.
The methodology to
gather rich information upon product perception, performance, and use are
consisted of performing:
- A survey of participants perceived needs from
products
- A semi-structured interview and cognitive
walkthrough focusing on daily tasks that included a discussion of ‘future
product use’
- Observational research in a controlled
environment including talk-aloud protocol.
Design must not only consider how usable or user-friendly a product
is but also how people feel when using that product or how that product, in
turn, makes them feel when using it. The goals of interaction designers are to
create interactive technologies that are enjoyable, pleasurable, motivating,
and satisfying, and these aims are largely dependent upon users’ acceptance of
technology, their perceptions of the technology and their level of engagement
with it. The significance of the participants’ individual prior experience was
perhaps more pronounced in the latter study exploring the development of
wheelchair design for active users. This heightened consideration of users and
focus upon user involvement has the potential to reduce development cost and
create more immediately usable and rewarding products. Members of the active
wheelchair user group felt stigmatised by features that identified them as
less-able and this also had implications upon mental health and self-esteem.
Participants indicated that aesthetics took precedence over almost all other
considerations, often even over functionality.
There are few constraints that needed to be taken into
consideration, like Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS). It revealed the extent to
which their mobility and movement were directly influenced by their limited
knowledge of access to rest rooms and toilets. Therefore, developing a mobility
aid with the functionality to detect, indicate, and navigate the user to the
nearest rest room facilities would be considered extremely incentivising. By
directly increasing the user’s mobility and confidence to travel and negotiate
busy and potentially congested environments, the benefit of using the device
would outweigh any negative perceptions of assistive technology use, and
actively encourage product adoption.
Evidence from the participatory design group interactions indicated
that store design and particularly the provision of seating were felt to be
insufficient for older users. Presumably allowing customers to rest between
purchases is insufficiently cost effective. Perhaps another way of conveying
the potential benefits of the proposed technology may be to develop the concept
of a smart shopper or product finder. This might allow users to enter their
shopping requirements and be guided in the most efficient manner to the
product, thus reducing the time and energy expended. This approach of involving
users heavily at the requirements gathering stage and accurately projecting the
potential of technology to enhance their lives appears to be gaining acceptance.
The argument that ‘Users don’t always know what they want’ has been
shown not to hold merit within the context of design and design teams hold an
equal responsibility to credibly portray the potential benefits of novel and new technologies to users. This
helps users visualize, understand, and comprehend, the capability new
technology offers. In a similar way to that in which Personas and Scenarios
help designers imagine and contextualize users, users may also require
assistance to imagine and conceptualize bespoke products designed with them in
mind. This systematic review has shown that technologies for mobility aid have
the potential to assist older people and people with disabilities to remain
mobile and to live safe and healthy lives at home (Alan J. Pearce 2012). Further research and training of the health and disability
workforces is needed to the adoption of robotics as an effective, routine, and
practical option within the home environment.
References:
Wilkinson, C. R. and A. De Angeli (2014). "Applying user centred and participatory design approaches to commercial product development." Design Studies 35(6): 614-631.
Alan J. Pearce, B. A., Kimberly
Miller, Elizabeth Ozanne, Catherine Said, Nick Santamaria, and Meg E. Morris
(2012). "Robotics to Enable Older Adults to Remain Living at Home."
Aging Research: 10.
Bright, K. and L. Coventry
(2013). Assistive technology for older adults: psychological and
socio-emotional design requirements. Proceedings of the 6th International
Conference on PErvasive Technologies Related to Assistive Environments. Rhodes,
Greece, ACM: 1-4.
L. Carelli, A. Gaggioli, G.
Pioggia, F. de Rossi, and G. Riva, “Affective robot for elderly assistance,”
Studies in Health Technology and Informatics, vol. 144, pp. 44–49, 2009.
M. A. Groves and V. F. Wilson, “To
move or not to move? Factors influencing the housing choice of elderly
persons,” Journal of Housing for the Elderly, vol. 10, pp. 33–47, 1992.
Paper 2:
PARTICIPATORY DESIGN SETS
NURSES FREE
Paper Title: Participatory Design of an Integrated
Information System Design to Support Public Health Nurses and Nurse Managers
Public health nurses (PHNs) and
nurse managers are a group of people dealing with an enormous amount of data recording,
information transmission and gathering. The special job scope puts them at both
the start point and the finish line of hospital information process circle. The
information obtained by them is so valuable that will soon reach other
departments for data analyzing and processing in order to treat patient timely,
efficiently, and effectively. However, until now, the data transmission in most
hospitals still rely on papers, which not only handicapped working efficiency,
but also cost significant waste of resources. Once the paper is compromised or
lost, the consequences could be disastrous.
Therefore, the design, development,
and implementation of integrated information systems that allow for analysis,
visualization, and exchange of data between and across public health
jurisdictions for different stakeholders in support of public health work has been
identified as a priority research area for public health informatics (Massoudi
et al., 2012). Current efforts to standardize the formats and uses of
electronic medical record data are intended to enhance interoperability and
facilitate data exchange between public health systems and clinical information
systems (Williams, Mostashari, Mertz, Hogin, & Atwal, 2012). Other efforts
specifically aim to support the work of public health nurses (PHNs) through the
implementation of data standards and information infrastructure (Issel,
Bekemeier, & Kneipp, 2012).
However, most of information
systems available at the market are not able to meet the demand for the largest
professional group of the public health workforce. The main reason behind this
awkwardness is that developers haven’t realized that they are in another
parallel world of PHNs, so that they are not capable of acquiring, identifying,
and understanding all of their important information needs. PHNs are strongly
affected by information system designs that do not fit their work.
During emergencies, PHNs play a key
role and require information systems that support continuity of operations
before, during, and after public health surge events (Rebmann, Carrico, &
English, 2008). Routine operations to deliver public health services are
characterized by the need to manage small emergencies on a regular basis
(Reeder & Turner, 2011). With recent initiatives to accelerate the adoption
of electronic medical records, there are higher expectations for information
exchange between clinical care and public health information systems. Thus,
there is a pressing need for integrated information systems designed to
seamlessly support PHNs and public health nurse managers (NMs) during normal
and emergency operations.
Under this great need, this study decided
to aim at three points: characterizing information needs of public health
nurses and nurse managers; creating a conceptual design of an integrated
information system; and conducting a preliminary validation of the conceptual
design. Based on these aims, participatory
design was introduced into this study.
Figure 1. Study Flow
Illustrating Data Collection, Design, and Validation Steps
Participatory design (originally
Cooperative Design, also known in the USA as co-design) is an approach to
design attempting to actively involve all stakeholders (e.g. employees,
partners, customers, citizens, end users) in the design process to help ensure
the result meets their needs and is usable. Besides, it draws on various
research methods (such as ethnographic observations, interviews, analysis of
artifacts, and sometimes protocol analysis), which are always used to
iteratively construct the emerging design.
Therefore, this study chose to
apply persona-driven and scenario-based design methods to create a conceptual
information system design to support public health nursing. Focus group,
interviews, and thematic analysis were used to characterize information needs
and solicit design recommendations from participants. Eventually, eighty nine
information needs were identified and further verified by health nurses and
nurse managers. In this health related study, the definition of an information
need is a person’s recognition that an information system should help her or
him know something, learn something, or do something better than if those same
activities were performed without the information system.
The
study results are quite informative and interesting. Participants identifyied
the idea of real-time documentation, which was highly valued by participants
from both LHDs for efficiency, convenience, and access of timely data from remote
locations. Besides, focus group participants from both LHDs validated the
conceptual design (information needs, personas, and scenarios of use) as
accurate with some suggestions for revisions. Participants suggested minor revisions
to make the personas more accurately reflect descriptions of real-world
practitioners. All recommendations suggested by participants were incorporated
into the personas and other design artifacts. What’s more, some differences
between sites emerged when it came to requested features and the emphasis of design
efforts. Agency A participants emphasized the need to correctly model work flow
for referrals and client record creation, while agency B PHN participants
wanted a feature to personally manage individual professional certifications
similar to the proposed feature available to managers.
As they explored participatory
design in this context, the lesson I learned is that limited resources create
an environment that people’s productivity is being wasted. A great tool will
significantly boost the efficiency and effectiveness. Another lesson learned is
that public health nurses and nurse managers are willing to engage in the
design of technology that supports their work. We should never have doubts on
the participants when doing requirement research, because they are the ones
holding the key to the door of magnificent system design.
In short, participatory design is
an approach that uses qualitative methods to directly engage people in the
design of systems they will use, and such approach definitely worth applying to
more special fields to serve the users and the developers.
References:
Issel, L. M., Bekemeier, B., & Kneipp, S. (2012). A public
health nursing research agenda. Public health Nursing, 29(4), 330–342.
Massoudi, B. L., Goodman, K. W., Gotham, I. J., Holmes, J.
H., Lang, L., Miner, K., et al. (2012). An informatics agenda for public health:
Summarized recommendations from the 2011 AMIA PHI Conference. Journal of the
American Medical Informatics Association, 19(5), 688–695.
Massoudi, B. L., Goodman, K. W., Gotham, I. J., Holmes, J.
H., Lang, L., Miner, K., et al. (2012). An informatics agenda for public health:
Summarized recommendations from the 2011 AMIA PHI Conference. Journal of the
American Medical Informatics Association, 19(5), 688–695.
Rebmann, T., Carrico, R., & English, J. F. (2008).
Lessons public health professionals learned from past disasters. Public Health
Nursing, 25(4), 344–352.
Reeder, B., & Turner, A. M. (2011). Scenario-based
design: A method for connecting information system design with public health
operations and emergency management. Journal of Biomedical Informatics, 44(6),
978–988.