In this post, we’ll be discussing about the 2 ubiquitous devices and its positive and negative usability issues.
Device 1: Amazon Echo
Amazon Echo is designed around your voice. It's always on—just ask for information, music, news, weather, creating shopping lists, to-do lists and more.
The Echo consists of two parts:
· A combined speaker / microphone device
· A software app.
The device is a cylinder-shaped speaker that stands upright. Its 9.25 inches tall and just 3.27 inches across. The speaker is omnidirectional (it broadcasts out to all sides).
It has seven microphones on the top, to pick up your voice from all directions. Echo begins working as soon as it detects the wake word. You can pick “Alexa” or “Amazon” as your wake word and “Alexa Stop” as the Stop word. These Start and stop words can be changed via the Echo App. It answers questions and performs simple tasks.
Echo requires an internet connection in order to work. Echo's voice recognition capability is based on Amazon Web Services and the Amazon common voice platform it acquired from Ivona. The Echo device works together with its cloud-based Echo App connected to the Internet. The app installed in the mobile/Tablet device enables Echo to create a shopping, To-Do lists which stores the information.
The device also comes with a manually and voice-activated remote control which can be used in lieu of the 'wake word'. Echo's microphones can be manually disabled by pressing a mute button to turn off the audio processing circuit. You simply address it by its name (“Alexa”) so it knows you are talking to it.
Let’s say you want to know the weather. You simply address it by its name (“Alexa”) so it knows you are talking to it. Then ask something like, “What’s the weather in Atlanta?” The Echo replies with appropriate weather for Atlanta at that moment. If the Echo is asleep, it will wake up. If it is playing music, it will stop and answer your question. The spoken answers also appear typed out in the app on your tablet or browser. The accompanying app can be used on the Kindle Fire, Android devices, and browsers. You can use the app even when you’re away from the speaker device.
Positive Usability:
- Echo is simple to set up and can be used by all age groups.
- The voice recognition is good, so we can speak naturally and it still picks up our commands anywhere within the vicinity unlike a robot.
- Echo caters the need for physically challenged deaf and blind people.
- The speaker delivers nice sound output. With Bluetooth you can connect tablets and phones and listen to music services such as Pandora and Spotify through the speaker.
Negative Usability:
- The device must be always connected to Mobile/Tablet via Bluetooth for playing the favorite songs since it doesn't have any memory storage.
- For small businesspeople looking for personal assistance tools, its limited mainly to looking up facts you can find online and creating simple lists.
- However, as the video below demonstrates, it can get stumped. Sometimes one word in the question makes a difference.
- The volume level is always constant and it doesn't sense according to the environment, the only way is to adjust manually.
- The devices is always connected to power since it doesn't hold a battery backup.
- Echo needs around 1-2 mins to initialize when the user changes the place of use.
Recommendations:
- If echo were tied
into recommendation engines like Yelp to get answers to questions
about things like “best pizza places,” restaurants etc to grab more interest from the
users. - Contextual Information - the future all of us expect, when our innate
computer system
can answer our far-reaching questions in the context we intend them. - Control of Other Functions - Echo is a simple step toward voice control over other
household functions (thermostat, lighting, locks, etc.) that are already fast finding
themselves a part of the "internet of things".
Related Videos:
References:
Amazon Echo update adds Pandora, iTunes, and Spotify voice control,
Amazon Echo: Fun, But Not Very Useful – Yet,
How private is Amazon Echo?
Device 2: SixthSense
SixthSense is a wearable gestural interface that augments
the physical world around us with digital information and lets us use natural
hand gestures to interact with that information.
SixthSense
bridges the gap between digital world and physical world, bringing intangible,
digital information out into the tangible world, and allowing us to interact
with this information via natural hand gestures. SixthSense frees information
from its confines by seamlessly integrating it with reality, and thus making
the entire world your computer.
The
SixthSense prototype is comprised of a pocket projector, a mirror and a camera,
which are coupled in a pendant like mobile wearable device. Both the projector
and the camera are connected to the mobile computing device in the user’s
pocket. The projector projects visual information enabling surfaces, walls and
physical objects around us to be used as interfaces; while the camera
recognizes and tracks user's hand gestures and physical objects using
computer-vision based techniques. The software program processes the video
stream data captured by the camera and tracks the locations of the colored
markers (visual tracking fiducials) at the tip of the user’s fingers using
simple computer-vision techniques. The movements and arrangements of these
fiducials are interpreted into gestures that act as interaction instructions
for the projected application interfaces. The maximum number of tracked fingers
is only constrained by the number of unique fiducials, thus SixthSense also
supports multi-touch and multi-user interaction.

The SixthSense prototype implements several applications that
demonstrate the usefulness, viability and flexibility of the system. The map
application lets the user navigate a map displayed on a nearby surface using
hand gestures, similar to gestures supported by Multi-Touch based systems,
letting the user zoom in, zoom out or pan using intuitive hand movements.
Besides, the SixthSense system implements a gestural camera that takes photos
of the scene the user is looking at by detecting the ‘framing’ gesture. The
user can stop by any surface or wall and flick through the photos he/she has
taken.
Positive Usability:
·
Due to its small size and portability, it can be easily carried around without
any difficulty.
·
The cost incurred for the construction of the Sixth Sense prototype is $300-$350,
which is quite low.
·
The user can easily access data from any machine at real time speed, and doesn’t
require any machine human interface to access the data.
·
The software that is used to interpret and
analysis the data collected by the device is made open source, which enables
other developers to contribute to the development of the system.
Negative
Usability:
·
The battery supplying the power of projector, microphone, and camera need to be
regularly replaced.
·
The color markers may cause discomfort after long-time use.
·
It is not easy to use the device when user is moving.
Recommendations:
·
Allow camera to capture and mark user’s fingers at first-time-use setting
stage, to get rid of color markers.
·
Change the battery to another kind with higher volume and smaller size.
·
Fix the pedant on cloth in case of dangling when user is on move.
Related Videos:
References:
P.
Mistry. The thrilling potential of SixthSense technology. TEDIndia 2009.
Mysore, India 2009
P.
Mistry, P. Maes, L. Chang. WUW - Wear Ur World - A Wearable Gestural Interface.
In the CHI '09 extended abstracts on Human factors in computing systems. Boston,
USA. 2009
P.
Maes, P. Mistry. Unveiling the "Sixth Sense," game-changing wearable
tech. TED 2009. Long Beach, CA, USA 2009
SixthSense:
A Wearable, Gestural Interface to Augment Our World




No comments:
Post a Comment