Blog #1 - Usability and User Experience (UX) Goals
This week we'll be looking at 2 good and 2 bad examples of websites in terms of usability and user experience. Usability and UX are terms open for interpretation and have different kinds of definitions and goals. Our take on the definitions is as follows:
Usability Goals
- Effectiveness - How good a system is at what it supposed to do, whether it is learnable and error-free
- Efficiency - How well a system supports users in carrying out their tasks, and if users can sustain their productivity once they have learned to use the system
- Safety - How the system helps users to recover from error(s) and reduce the risk of users mistakenly activating these errors. The system should also bring about confidence and allow users to explore the UI
- Utility – How the system provides for all the necessary functionalities to carry out all of the required tasks
- Learnability - How easy it is for users to learn how to use the system through exploration
- Memorability – How well the user can remember how to use the system after learning, and whether they are able to remember how to perform tasks
User Experience Goals
User experience conveys the user’s feeling after using the system, be it desirable or undesirable. Some of these aspects are listed below:
- Desirable Aspects – satisfying, helpful, engaging, exciting, fun, etc...
- Undesirable Aspects – unpleasant, frustrating, annoying, boring, etc...
The Good
Case #1 - NS.sg
>> Web: www.NS.sg
Mention NS.sg to any Singaporean male and they would tell you that it is the most horrible site ever – that was before the revamp. The site allows males serving their national service in Singapore to report and schedule their national service activities online. After the revamp significant changes have enhanced the user experience on the site, which is now more user-centric – allowing users to browse by persona. For those who need quick access, shortcuts are also included to cater for task-based navigation to popular e-services like IPPT booking.
NS.sg prides itself to serve all the national servicemen from SAF to the hometeam personnel. Its effectiveness as a site to serve national servicemen is pretty good at the same time, it is able to inform users of the latest news there is happening.
The NS.sg site offers to help user throughout their NS lifecycle - from a pre-enlistee to an NSmen, from booking your IPPT to applying for exit permit, all serve via this single website. The layout of the site makes it a very user friendly one because it give the user options to choose via their profile or their task. It is a pleasure to use this site because it doesn’t frustrate users and it helps users to get their NS obligation done.
In terms of usability goals, NS.sg meets most of the criteria:
- Effectiveness - simplistic layout without over cluttering the site with information
- Efficiency - The loading time is almost immediate, same goes for the processing time. This can be attributed to the minimalist design of the site.
- Safety - The navigation bar is always on the top, thus users don’t get lost easily. Also whenever there is a transaction involved, there will be confirmation prompt
- Utility – Most of the popular services are offered via this site
- Learnability - site is very user friendly, navigating through the site is an ease
- Memorability – the layout of the site enable user to go to the needed sites without needing to remembering
Case #2 - eCommerce Site
>> Web: www.eties.it/en
Eties have been specialising in the production and distribution of ties since 1954. The website allows you to browse and purchase ties and accessories according to design and make. As an e-commerce website, conversion is important, and this shows through their simple and clear UI that is both functional and aesthetically pleasing.
The website exudes the charm that they seek to project through their products. When you land on the homepage, you are greeted with stylish ties set against men with smart suits. Clean, bold words entice you to click on the category that you think best suits your style and personality. The experience is pleasurable even If you are not a visual person - eties allows you to browse for “one of a kind”, “new in” or even “designer” ties. The use of more descriptive words allows the layman to understand and appreciate how ties are classified on the site. Browsing for ties and accessories through a clean user interface is a pleasure and you will feel empowered and compelled to buy a tie or two amongst all the choices presented to you.
In terms of usability goals, eties meets most of the criteria:
- Effectiveness - easy to read fonts, good contrast - black text on white
- Efficiency - reasonable loading time
- Safety - the site keeps track of the selected items on the right, which allows users to undo or redo their selection
- Utility - top navigation with clear and concise labels
- Learnability - company logo links back to homepage; back to top button included to scroll back to the beginning of the page
- Memorability – users are able to repeat step-by-step selection on the top navigation to filter to the ties that they fancy
The Bad
Case #1 - Taxi booking Site
>> Web: Webbooking.cdgtaxi.com.sg/home.mvn
The ComfortDelgro taxi booking website allows you to submit your taxi booking requests online. The design and user interface predates Web 2.0 conventions, and while it meets basic usability standards for a desktop era, it is lacking in the more usable and easy to use features of mobile location based taxi booking applications.
User experience of the website is also not up to par in today’s context. It is frustrating and annoying to fill in so many forms just to book a taxi.
In terms of usability goals, taxi booking does not meet most of the criteria:
- Effectiveness - The website allows you to complete your transaction online, but may require more effort to find the right taxi booking
- Efficiency - While the website has an autopopulate address function based on zipcode, the zipcode is not placed above the address field to indicate that users do not need to enter the address manually but can “get the address” by filling in their zipcode. The mobile version of the site does not allow geolocation features such as detecting your current address based on your location. You will have to manually input the address and postal code of your current location to make a booking.
- Safety - The website is lacking in safety in terms of not being able to reject a taxi booking based on the driver’s quality. Modern booking apps allow you to accept or reject an available taxi based on the taxi’s ratings by other users.
- Utility – The website does not meet in today’s mobile-centric context. It does not support user preferences of taxi type or destination, which means that frequent users will have to select the taxi type & destination for each new booking. This can be easily avoided if the system remembers the user’s frequently chosen options. Another utility the website is lacking is the ability to see the location of taxis. You are only greeted by a processing screen that asks you to wait for a taxi to be confirmed. In modern taxi booking apps, you are able to see the taxi’s location and its movements, allowing you to judge more accurately the estimated time of arrival.
- Learnability - As a more savvy user, you would be able to get used to the system. If you were a new user, you will require more time to struggle through the interface.
- Memorability – Compared to modern booking apps where you merely need to tap a button to start signalling for a taxi based on your current location. It is not nearly as satisfying also to not know where your current booked taxi is currently, compared to modern apps where you are able to have full visibility of the taxi’s movement on whether its reaching or not.
Case #2 - eCommerce Site
>> Web: www.arngren.net
Arnger.net is an e-Commerce website from Norway. Surfing this site is an annoying experience because the design the site feels gimmicky and is not optimised for the web. Listing out the products in a haphazard way makes the browsing experience very unpleasant and the website in general leaves an unprofessional aftertaste.
In terms of usability goals, taxi booking does not meet most of the criteria:
- Effectiveness - Arnger.net is not very effective due to the scattered product listings and the product description is not sufficient for you to proceed for product selection.
- Efficiency - Horizontal scrolling slows you down when navigating the site
- Safety - While browsing the products, you are transported to pages with varying layouts. In these pages, no category navigation options are provided. The only way back is to click on the logo on the top navigation.
- Utility – The search label is not visible enough for you to search through the products and get proper information. It is not intuitive to navigate around the site and does not return proper product search results.
- Learnability - The products are listed in the various dimensions and formats, hence it doesn't give a consistent look and feel throughout the site. Exploration on the site is also a challenge.
- Memorability – The layout of this website reminds you of a flyer, and not a website. Products are all over the place without proper categorisation. On your next visit, if ever, you would probably not remember what was where on the website and have to start your search all over.
No comments:
Post a Comment